17:00
Cambridge University
November 24
Robinson College
The Baxandall Visiting Fellow at Robinson College, Dr Jashim Chowdhury delivers a lecture entitled "Can Courts Save the Environment Without Weakening Democracy? Rethinking Environmental Judicial Activism in South Asia". In his lecture, Dr Jashim Chowdhury looks into the matter of the environmental constitutionalism which has empowered courts to respond where political institutions appear unwilling or unable to act. In India, Pakistan and Bangladesh, however, this expansion of judicial authority raises a neglected question: can environmentally progressive judgments nevertheless be democratically deficient? Drawing on his forthcoming book, Dr Chowdhury examines a pattern of environmental adjudication that is normatively ambitious but frequently less inclusive, less democratic and more combative than its objectives require. In his lecture he argues that the central challenge is not choosing between judicial activism and restraint, but reimagining the relationship between courts, legislatures, governments and affected communities. Bringing South Asian jurisprudence into conversation with deliberative democracy and dialogic judicial review, the lecture develops a model of collaborative environmental adjudication. Under this model, courts do not abandon rights enforcement; rather, they employ participatory and dialogue-promoting remedies that distribute responsibility, improve public justification and make environmental reform more democratically legitimate and institutionally sustainable.